[Biggest 
Islamic 
web site in the 
U.S.]
P.O. Box 356, Kingsville, MD 21087.
Phone: 410-435-5000.
Disclaimer: Views expressed are not necessarily 
shared by editorial committee.
Responses (positive or negative) up to 250 words are welcome.
Names will be withheld on request.
--------------------------------------------
Wife's "Obedience": Men and Women are Each 
Other's Guardians
Children who do not see their mothers respected 
as Decision-makers can be 
harmed mentally
[Ref: Our discussion of the 
Qur'an 4:34]
I am happy to see that someone has been mature 
enough and felt secure enough 
about their manhood to speak out 
.....finally...... for once........ about the 
topic. "The wife's obedience to her husband 
issue".
There is not a doubt in my mind that the wife as 
well as the husband should 
have equal respect for each others feelings, 
concerns and desires. However, 
this idea of the husband treating the wife as a 
child and expecting her to be 
blindly obedient, and childlike as opposed to 
being mature minded and an adult as 
he, breeds really an unsettlling and 
non-productive relationships in families 
and the society as a whole. 
Children reared in that kind of an environment 
lose respect for the mother's 
opinion and fail to trust her decision-making 
ability in the husband's 
absence. Allah has said that husbands and wives 
are the protectors of each other. If 
the wife never gets to be considered as an adult 
and equal partner, her 
ability to make sound judgements is impaired. It 
is only through sharing, respecting 
and mutual consultations, giving and sharing that 
husbands and wives can grow 
into healthy, meaningful, loving relationships.
I think that part of the problems that are in the 
Muslim world stem from the 
fact that men do not seek the Muslim women's 
views. Women process information 
differently than men .......they also think and 
reason differently from that 
of men. These assets are valuable when brought to 
the discussion table with 
men's ideals. This creates a wholistic view of 
things and it enhances 
relationships, builds better, more productive 
families and sound societies. Allah has 
made husbands and wives partners. A good 
businessman want a wise partner in his 
camp so that he can be successful. Yet, some 
Muslim men fail to realize the 
benefit and value of the Muslim women's opinions 
and ability to aide in decision 
making.
This topic really needs more research and group 
discussions in the Muslim 
community. I hope you will continue to add to 
your previous discussion on an 
ongoing basis. Muslim men really need to hear 
this from other Muslim men.
Thanks again for your eye opening, thought 
provoking and most beneficial 
contribution to the topic. Sincerely,
Wa salaam, Amatullah V. Abdul-Karim
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
2003-08-02 Sat 19:14ct